Do it yourself
Cancel Bullymake yourself
TLDR: Sign in, open the Subscription tab, and click disable auto-renewal, or email customercare@bullymake.com. That stops the next plan, not the boxes left on the plan you already bought, and a multi-month plan can add an early cancellation fee.
Turn off auto-renewal in your account
Your plan is eligible to cancel online. Bullymake's own article describes this button.
- 01Go to bullymake.com and sign in.
- 02Open the Subscription tab.
- 03Scroll to the bottom and click the disable auto-renewal button.
Disabling auto-renewal is not the same as ending the boxes you already committed to. The FAQ says you still get the remaining shipments, and no more after that plan is finished.
Cancel by email
The button is missing, or you want the request in writing. The FAQ and subscription terms both name this address.
- 01Email customercare@bullymake.com.
- 02Give your name and the email on the account.
- 03Say you want auto-renewal off, or that you want to cancel, and ask them to confirm what is still due.
Cancel by chat
You want an answer on the site. The FAQ says to use the chat in the bottom right.
- 01Open bullymake.com and start the live chat in the bottom right.
- 02If chat is closed, send a message. The contact page says that opens a ticket and they reply by email.
- 03Say you want the subscription cancelled and keep the transcript.
How to know it worked
- Bullymake does not describe a cancellation number. Keep the email reply or the chat transcript.
- Turning off auto-renewal stops the next plan. It does not stop the shipments left on the plan you already bought.
- A cancel that misses the day before renewal applies to the following term. Their example is a July 15 three-month plan that renews October 15 unless they have the request by October 14.
Watch out for
- A one-month plan can be cancelled at any time without an extra fee, once you are past the first commitment the FAQ describes.
- A multi-month plan is a commitment for the length you picked. Cancel before the last box of that plan and the subscription terms charge a one-time early cancellation fee based on the rate of that plan. They do not publish a dollar amount for the fee.
- The FAQ example: a 6 month plan can be cancelled without that fee after the 6th shipment. The terms use a 3 month plan the same way, before the 3rd shipment.
- After the first plan is finished, a cancel in the auto-renewal period takes effect at the end of the current billing cycle, and the terms say there is no early cancellation fee.
- The terms say they will not refund unshipped boxes in the middle of the current subscription, and they will not refund a subscription after it has already renewed.
Bullymake refunds
- Accepted orders are final except where the subscription terms say otherwise. Do not expect a refund just because you cancelled.
- An early cancel before the committed boxes are done can add a one-time fee. It does not, by itself, refund boxes already in the plan.
- Bullymake's Promise is a replacement toy, not a subscription refund. Email a photo to customercare@bullymake.com within 45 days of receiving the toy.
Sources · checked 26 October 2026
